Gonzales breaks the rules of lying
The first rule of lying is that you never lie about something that can be verified.
The second rule of lying is that you don't do it without a good reason.
The third rule of lying is that if you do it, the lie has to be plausible.
The fourth rule of lying is that once you've lied, you have to keep your story straight.
Alberto Gonzales violates every rule. There are contemporaneous documents and no fewer than 10 eyewitnesses that prove without question that Gonzales lied to the Senate Judiciary Committee about the visit to Ashcroft's hospital room.
There was no motive for Gonzales to lie. In his attempt to explain why he'd gone to Ashcroft's bedside, it didn't matter whether it was about the terrorist surveillance program or some other program.
In addition, Gonzales' lie was not plausible. He claimed he'd gone to Ashcroft's bedside only to inform Ashcroft that the acting attorney general, Comey, wasn't going to reauthorize the program -- he says he was simply conveying information. However, when questioned by Sheldon Whitehouse, Gonzales was forced to admit that he had a piece of paper in his hand when he went to see Ashcroft, and that this piece of paper was a memo reauthorizing the program -- a memo that needed only Ashcroft's signature.
On top of all that, Gonzales can't keep his story straight. After the Bush administration has consistently denied the existence of surveillance programs other than the one knows as TSP, Gonzales said he'd gone to see Ashcroft to talk about programs other than the TSP. Clearly he was so confused by the hostile questions that he forgot what the previous administration lies were, and so was unable to keep his story straight.
If this guy doesn't resign, he's going to be impeached. In fact, he might be impeached after he resigns.
